User:Fredddie/Rubric

Rubric

1. Lead and infobox – 5 points
   • Infobox complete with map (1)
   • Lead adequately summarizes the route description (2)
     • Yes (2)
     • Needs work (1)
     • No (0)
     • Detracts (-1)
   • Lead adequately summzaries the history (2)
     • Yes (2)
     • Needs work (1)
     • No (0)
     • Detracts (-1)
2. Route description – 20 points
   • Length of section is appropriate for the length of the highway (2)
     • Appropriate (2)
     • Too short (1)
     • Missing (0)
     • Too long (-1)
   • Quality of the prose (15) 5 points each
     • Informative
     • Complete
     • Concise
       • Satisfactory (5)
       • Adequate (4)
       • Unsatisfactory (3)
       • Needs rework (2)
       • No (1)
       • Missing (0)
       • Detracts (-1)
   • References (3) 1 point each
     • Varied sources
     • Not reliant on maps
     • Accurate
3. History – 20 points
   • Length of section is appropriate for the age of the highway (2)
     • Appropriate (2)
     • Too short (1)
     • Missing (0)
     • Too long (-1)
   • Quality of the prose (15) 5 points each
     • Informative
     • Complete
     • Concise
       • Satisfactory (5)
       • Adequate (4)
       • Unsatisfactory (3)
       • Needs rework (2)
       • No (1)
       • Missing (0)
       • Detracts (-1)
   • References (3) 1 point each
     • Varied sources
     • Not reliant on maps
     • Accurate
4. Junction list – 3 points
   1. Standard lists
      • Every junction has a milepost
      • Every possible junction has a control city
      • Lengths cited
      • Appropriate notes
      • Uses templates correctly
   2. Bulleted lists
      • Shows every major highway (US: Interstates, U.S. Highways, other freeways)
      • Does not show minor highways (US: state and county highways)
      • Control cities listed
      • Formatted correctly
5. Miscellaneous – 2 points
   • Appropriate photos
   • Appropriate categories
   • Follows MURA
   • Lacks cleanup templates
   • Meets accessibility standards

Scoring

• A-Class - 55 points and two formal reviews (ACR and BCR)
• B-Class - 50 points and one formal review (BCR)
• C-Class - 40 points
• D-Class - 30 points
• E-Class - <30 points